Atif Syed, a computer engineer from AMU, turns historian and deftly narrates the layered story of the city in a storytelling style. Atif’s exploration moves from Aligarh’s origin under the Dor Rajputs.
The mere mention of Aligarh brings to mind images of “padlocks and pairs of scissors” or, as author Rakhshanda Jalil and millions of Aligarh Muslim University alumni spread across the world say, the city evokes a deep sense of “Ahd-e-Rafta” (the days gone by). The mention of the town triggers rich mental images of the historic Aligarh Muslim University (AMU) campus, its iconic tree-lined avenues, vintage cinema halls like Tasveer Mahal, and old family havelis.
In Aligarh: The City That Outlasted Empires [Hachette], Atif Syed, a computer engineer from AMU, turns historian and deftly narrates the layered story of the city in a storytelling style. The reader gets mesmerised by the sheer prose as Atif’s exploration moves from Aligarh’s origin under the Dor Rajputs, through Qutbuddin Aibak’s conquest to the Mughal era. He then turns to the stormy years of European intervention, which gave way to the founding of Aligarh Muslim University in the wake of the 1857 uprising, the great Indian revolt. Thankfully, Atif does not confine himself to the role and contributions of Syed Ahmed Khan but expands into a labyrinth of stories about ordinary citizens who adapted and rebuilt with each change of power, and the powerful whose ambitions reshaped Aligarh’s course.
Atif’s work skilfully explores diverse facets of local life, including French soldiers composing Urdu poetry, global merchant networks, indigo plantation economies, and historical architecture (temples, mosques, tombs, and forts). Take, for instance, his description of Lord Richard Wellesley’s orders to General Lord Lake in the sweltering heat on 7 August 1803, leading a force of 5,000 infantry, 2,500 cavalry, and standard artillery support to Kanpur.
“The sun blazed mercilessly, turning the earth into a furnace, but the determination in the soldiers’ eyes burned even brighter. The formidable fortress of Aligarh, a bastion of strength in Hindustan, lay in the north of Koil town, separated by a plain. This fortress, a marvel of French engineering, boasted massive walls, reinforced corner towers, and a moat so vast and deep that ships could sail within its waters. It stood as a symbol of Maratha might, seemingly impregnable.”
By 26 August 1803, Lake’s forces had reached Sikandra Rao, presently famous for its khurchan, the scraped, gooey layers of malai, a town about forty kilometres southeast of Aligarh.
“General Lake received official authorization from the Governor-General to commence active military operations, enter Maratha territory, and prepare for the next major showdown at Aligarh. British officers also received intelligence that Pierre Cuillier-Perron (General Perron), a French mercenary commander who controlled the strategic Aligarh Fort on behalf of the Maratha Empire, was positioned at Koil and intended to engage them, relying primarily on his cavalry—considered the finest irregular horsemen in Hindustan. The Maratha forces at Koil were comparable in size to the British army, numbering 2,000 infantry, 8,000 cavalry, and the usual complement of artillery, all under Perron’s command. The following day, Lake’s forces moved closer to Koil and Aligarh Fort, and on 28 August, they finally came within sight of the Jama Masjid in Koil, where they encamped.”
Meanwhile, a bigger drama was unfolding in the Maratha camp. Nine English and country-born officers in Daulat Rao Scindia’s service—among them James Skinner, Captain Stewart, and Captain Carnegie—decided not to fight against the British. Consequently, they were dismissed, paid their arrears, and ordered to quit the Maratha army.
The following morning, on 29 August, Lake’s forces approached from the southeast and found Perron’s forces strongly positioned at Koil. Rather than launch a frontal assault on the town’s southern defences, Lake ordered his cavalry to swing considerably to the right, turning the enemy’s left flank and bypassing a deep morass that protected the Maratha front. The battle opened with probing actions from both sides. The Maratha cavalry amassed for what appeared to be a major assault, presenting an opportunity to strike at an exposed flank of Lake’s force—but no order to attack came. A few concentrated volleys from the British horse artillery sent the riders reeling back in disarray. Retreating to the fort to the north, they attempted to retaliate with cannon fire, though their hasty shots fell wide.
Though Lake had hoped to provoke a decisive engagement, even this brief skirmish proved consequential. The display of British firepower dealt a severe blow to Perron’s authority, causing several key allies to desert. Soon, a shocking revelation hit both camps when General Perron abruptly announced his departure, claiming he would bring reinforcements from Agra and Delhi. The French commander’s last act was to pen a fervent letter to Colonel Pedron, his stout deputy, known for his gold-rimmed spectacles and distinctive green uniform. The letter exhorted Pedron to defend the fort to the last—a command steeped in irony as Perron himself fled the field of battle. His actions revealed stark hypocrisy: he demanded unwavering courage from his subordinates while demonstrating none himself. His letter invoked national pride: “Remember your French heritage,” he wrote, “and let none of your actions dishonour our nation. Within five days, I will either return with the English General as my prisoner, or faster than I departed. Have no concerns on this matter—either the Emperor’s forces or General Lake shall find their grave at Aligarh. Do your duty and hold the fort while a single man remains to fight.”
The Maratha forces were in disarray, and Perron fled the scene with a few horsemen. On his retreat, dishevelled and hatless, he encountered the Anglo-Indian officers from the Maratha army whom he had dismissed just days earlier, camped in a garden near the Sasni Gate. They had been let go for refusing to fight against the British. Among them was James Skinner—a junior cavalry officer of mixed Scottish and Rajput descent, popularly known as “Sikandar Sahib”—who immediately approached the fleeing general, stating that he had come to remonstrate against his dismissal and was determined to share Perron’s fortunes.
“Ah! No, no!” replied Perron. “It is all over; these fellows (the horse) have behaved ill. Do not ruin yourself; go over to the British. It is all up with us.”
Skinner pushed back: “By no means. It is not so. Let us rally yet and make a stand—you may depend upon having many yet to fight for you.”
But Perron shook his head and replied in broken English: “Ah, no, Monsieur Skinner—I not trust—not trust; I am afraid you all go.”
This infuriated Skinner, who accused Perron of being a traitor and roared, “Then you may go to the devil!” Before returning to his comrades, he resolved to report the whole ordeal to Daulat Rao Scindia. Perron, his mind made up, left Aligarh for good, never to return.
Atif goes on to narrate how General Lake soon captured Koil.
“He moved northwards, deployed his forces along the town’s northern perimeter, and established his temporary military headquarters at Sahib Bagh, Perron’s garden house, located not far from the fort. With the Governor-General’s support, Lake spent the next few days attempting to turn Perron’s soldiers against him, particularly targeting Colonel Pedron, who served as the fort’s key defender alongside Perron. He even sent Thomas Long Croft, an indigo planter from Jalali, to persuade Pedron. Although Pedron was willing to surrender the fort, the remaining Maratha troops refused to capitulate and prevented his defection. They seized Colonel Pedron, briefly imprisoned their French commander, and rallied under their chosen leader, Baji Rao, a Bhaduria Rajput. According to British sources, these negotiations over the fort’s surrender may also have been part of a deceptive French-Maratha strategy to buy time for completing a mine under the fort’s only entrance, making the conquest more challenging.”
At this point, Atif meticulously records that entering British service was the furthest thing from James Skinner’s mind. A soldier of fortune in every sense, he wanted nothing more than to live and die under Scindia’s colours. Britain held little appeal for him—his father was gone, his brother had settled in Begum Sumru’s service in Sardhana, and his other relatives were little more than strangers.
It was Captain Carnegie who broke the deadlock. Speaking plainly, he argued that Scindia would never truly trust them again—they would be watched with suspicion, starved of promotion, and perhaps worse. Their best hope was to seek protection from the British commander. Skinner resisted strongly; he knew little of his countrymen and placed little faith in British promises. Finally, Carnegie’s argument won him over, and Skinner joined Lake’s army alongside nine other English and country-born officers.
Meanwhile, things were far from easy for General Lake’s troops. A severe drought had gripped Koil and the region in 1803 as a result of an extraordinary monsoon failure. The relentless heat was merciless, leaving many soldiers struggling to endure the punishing conditions. Driven by desperation, they resorted to drinking from muddy pools just to survive. Nature’s fury did not end there. At midnight on 1 September 1803, the ground itself turned hostile—a powerful earthquake shook the region for about two minutes, reducing several buildings in the town of Koil to rubble and deepening the chaos.
Atif’s Aligarh is particularly recommended to all those interested in history, military warfare, and strategic crossroads. His fascinating account of European powers integrating into Indian political formations is worth reading and relishing