Categories: Opinion

America’s war with Iran without Afghanistan and ‘what if…’

Published by Don Ritter & A. Nazar
Last updated June 14, 2026 03:22:07 IST

If Afghanistan had remained a strategic partner of the United States until today, what would the U.S. war with Iran have looked like? A sustained and active U.S. presence in Afghanistan could have played a significant role in decisively winning a conflict with Iran

Afghanistan has pretty much disappeared from Western public view save for an occasional story of brutality towards women and girls or a TikTok video showing some 9-year-old girl being married off—sold really—to an elderly man. Add to that, the very recent battles between the Taliban and their Pakistani creators and enablers is an historic irony of “chickens coming home to roost”. Another great irony is that Pakistan, which was the driving military force behind the Taliban war effort and the resulting American exit from Afghanistan, is now the mediator between Iran and the United States!

Since February 28, 2026, the United States has engaged in a war with Iran, a country which shares a 512-mile border with Afghanistan… and the U.S. is no longer there. At the time this article is being written that war is far from over as the Iranian regime clings to power despite massive bombing of military and regime targets, the decapitation of their top leadership and a blockade of Iranian ports. Closing the Straits of Hormuz, Iran holds the global economy hostage.

“BOOTS ON THE GROUND”

Commentators talk of arming a resistance to the regime as providing the crucial “boots on the ground” necessary to overthrow the stubborn existing power structure including war criminals who would be held accountable by the Iranian people. Staying in power for those in the regime is a way to stay alive, meaning they are not going to surrender easily, certainly not to aircraft.

Infiltration of Iranian guerrilla fighters across the border would be a natural military option. Right now, our side does not have a viable way to bring guns and supplies to the people who would resist and go on the offensive. Resistance fighters would do what aircraft carriers, F-35s and B1 bombers, coming from a thousand or more miles away cannot do and that is keep regime elements like the Basij from beating and killing protesters, plus they could take and hold positions and territory inside Iran.

Also, with American forces and bases on the other side of the border, the Iranian regime would have to position substantial military resources to deter incursion along the long and mountainous border on their eastern frontier. It would be the regime’s nightmare to defend against infiltration across such a border. Considering U.S. control of the airspace, and proximity for drone warfare, prospects for success of such resistance would appear to be quite positive.

The Afghan nation once was a staunch ally of the United States on the regional stage. The alliance dates back to the days when America supported the Afghan resistance in throwing out their Soviet invaders in the 1980s which contributed to the collapse of the Soviet Union and the end of the Cold War. Not only were the Afghan people supporters of America and Americans and hopeful of creating a (more or less) democratic way of life but the military infrastructure we created and left behind there was enormously powerful in both size and capacity.

If Afghanistan had remained a strategic partner of the United States until today, what would the U.S. war with Iran have looked like?

Answer: A sustained and active U.S. presence in Afghanistan could have played a significant role in decisively winning a conflict with Iran.

America left behind some trillion dollars’ worth of Forward Operating Bases (FOBs), which are virtually impregnable fortresses, bastions of concrete and steel, with long runways and vast electronic intelligence and surveillance capacity.

The Shindand airbase outside of Herat is just 75 miles from the 512-mile eastern Iranian border with Afghanistan and some 450 miles from Tehran compared with long-term deployment, energy-hungry aircraft carriers and refueling aircraft-supporting fighter and bomber missions of some 1000 to 1500 miles away from Iran. Having land-based capabilities would have been highly complementary to our predominantly sea-based effort.

Most importantly, the Shindand base would likely be the jumping-off location for inserting Iranian resistance fighters into the battle. Close air support of resistance fighters could have been provided virtually unimpeded movement given the decimation of Iranian air forces and air defenses.

Bagram Air Base, outside Kabul, some 572 miles from the Iranian border, and the most important military base in Afghanistan and the entire region, could have played a central role in any potential U.S. operation against Iran. Geographically, logistically, and militarily, it had enormous capacity to support both air and ground operations. Being some 425 miles from its nuclear heartland, Bagram also offered a sobering deterrent to China.

In addition to Shindand and Bagram, the United States maintained important military bases in Afghanistan, in Mazar-i-Sharif, Kandahar, Helmand, Nangarhar/Jalalabad and Khost. These installations, each equipped with advanced electronic systems, trained personnel, and extensive logistical, transportation, and intelligence infrastructure—meaning human as well as electronic intelligence gathering—provided added platforms for training, intelligence gathering, military movement and force projection. They were also giant armories to potentially provide weapons to Iranian resistance fighters.

In sum, given proximity to the Iranian border, expanded signals intelligence, human intelligence gathering and most importantly, the presence of a land connection to put resistance “boots on the ground”, Iranian boots, would have significantly advanced our military capabilities, making for real victory, meaning taking down the Iranian regime once and for all, achievable. Victory over a large country like Iran with air power alone is much more difficult, as we are learning daily.

This what if…? scenario is moot given total U.S. withdrawal and Taliban control of Afghanistan, but the lessons of history are not. America’s strategic decisions based on short-term political calculation can be incredibly damaging to our longer-range geopolitical security. While the political implications within Afghanistan of an American war against Iran may not have been certain, the potential for a clear victory, by pressuring Iran from the east as well as the west and getting “boots on the ground”, would have been significantly enhanced.

Bottom line: We should have remained in Afghanistan.

  • Former U.S. Rep. Don Ritter is the President and CEO Emeritus of the Afghan American Chamber of Commerce. He has forty years of continuous experience with Afghanistan, starting with the Soviet invasion of Afghanistan in 1979. He has published numerous articles on Afghanistan; the last one was published on the third anniversary of America’s withdrawal. He currently serves as Chairman of The Remembrance Society.

Co-author A. Nazari, is a former General in the Afghan Army, and top security advisor to post-9/11 Afghan governments, prominent international (including Iran) businessman and a community leader with a following in the millions among the Afghan population.

Tushar Sharma
Published by Don Ritter & A. Nazar
Last updated June 14, 2026 03:22:07 IST