The “Vote Chori” campaign by the Opposition parties that are also demanding the removal of Chief Election Commissioner, Gyanesh Kumar, has put the Central government and the Bharatiya Janata Party on the backfoot. Repeated attempts by the saffron brigade to divert attention and create a new narrative, do not seem to be succeeding. The issue has become the talking point of the common people and unless the government takes appropriate steps, things may further worsen.
The Apex Court is hearing some petitions, but what should worry those in power is that the credibility of the Election Commission has to be restored, both for preserving the sanctity of the Constitutional body and the belief of the average citizen in a fair democratic process. Rahul Gandhi, Leader of Opposition in the Lok Sabha, may have admitted that evidence to establish any wrongdoing was being collected, but the fact is that the perception game is tilting towards the parties which are against the government in general, and the Chief Election Commissioner in particular.
The principal reason for the changing perception is that the BJP’s stranglehold over social media has loosened and young people, who are not convinced by the official explanations, are countering every tweet or post put up by the supporters of the government. In politics, perception matters and though the reality is that the government is firmly in place, the developments should be perturbing those who are in power.
The “change of regime” demands echoed by mostly students and activists with left leanings, may be part of their political messaging, but it has to be understood by one and all, that there is no substitute for toppling a government except through the ballot. Therefore, this matter should neither be exaggerated by the ruling alliance nor by those having political ambitions. Sunday’s rally at the Ramlila ground could be the beginning of a long struggle to demand justice and fair play in the electoral process.
The agitation is based on the assumption that elections were rigged, and the outcome of the Assembly polls in Bengal, Bihar, Haryana and some other places, was achieved by eliminating crores of voters from the electoral list as well as some technical manipulations. The Apex Court may come out with some answers regarding certain anomalies, but it shall take a lot more to restore the confidence of the people in the Election Commission’s ability to conduct fair and free polls. Elections to the Assembly of five states are due early next year and it is essential that the issue is sorted out before that to the satisfaction of all concerned.
Ramlila ground in Central Delhi is a historic venue. It was here at the fag end of Emergency in January, 1977, that Jai Prakash Narayan addressed a public meeting. This particular gathering did not have very large attendance but did convey the anguish of the common man. However, a few days later, when Babu Jagjivan Ram along with Hemvati Nandan Bahuguna and some others walked out of the Congress to form the Congress for Democracy, the fear factor was gone.
Consequently, the public meeting he addressed at the Ramlila ground, had unprecedented numbers. Every path leading towards the venue was choked with people and after Babuji as Jagjiwan Ram was referred to, finished his speech, the writing was on the wall for Indira Gandhi that her days were numbered. The rally on Sunday may not be as mammoth as that of the veteran leader, but there would be messaging all the same.
The attack on the Election Commission, would be also an attack on the government as well as its functionaries. However, whether this aggression can be sustained by an opposition divided on many other matters is to be seen. From what it appears as of now, there is complete unity so far as demand for the removal of the Chief Election Commissioner is concerned. Rahul Gandhi is also facing criticism within his own party for giving more weightage to left oriented activists at the cost of his own party’s supporters.
It is a serious issue that needs to be addressed sooner than later, since the ideologies of the Congress and the leftists are at variance with each other. Indira Gandhi had once leaned towards the left, at the behest of some of her Kashmiri advisers led by P.N. Haksar and D.P. Dhar, both top level intellectuals. Her critics accused her of succumbing to pressure and adopting the Kumaramanglam thesis; Mohan Kumaramanglam was a Union Minister with left background who had rehabilitated many of his erstwhile associates in the Congress party.
Matters came to a head when in a contest between the Nehru Forum and Socialist Forum, within the Congress, the gap between the leftists and the rest had closed. The two forums were disbanded. The late Sanjay Gandhi, who helped the Congress comeback in 1980, had in a meeting with RSS leaders, made it clear that he was not anti-Muslim, as was being made out to be. However, the two sides could have a dialogue since both were opposed to the leftist politics.
After his passing away, M.L. Fotedar, a disciple of D.P. Dhar, who was appointed by Indira Gandhi as her adviser, never allowed the left to have an upper hand in dealings with the Congress. The focus of current politics of the opposition is the removal of the CEC. Possibly many tactical adjustments may have to be made to achieve that. Between us.