There are signs that Gyaltsen Norbu, who was enthroned as the XIth Panchen Lama by China, is possibly not measuring up to the Chinese leadership’s requirements.
China has long sought to undermine the XIVth Dalai Lama’s influence among Tibetans and with the demise of the Xth Panchen Lama, perceived an opportunity to appoint a Panchen Lama and eventually take over the leadership of Tibetan Buddhists. It incarcerated the Xth Panchen Lama’s reincarnation selected by the XIVth Dalai Lama and in 1995 replaced him with Gyaltsen Norbu, who it subsequently enthroned as the XIth Panchen Lama.
Since then Gyaltsen Norbu has been taught religious texts and sent on tours to Tibet to give religious teachings and be accepted by the Tibetan people as the rightful Panchen Lama. Tibetans, however, regard him as a “learned monk” but are yet unwilling to accept him as the Panchen Lama.
China has also since 2006 sought to introduce Gyaltsen Norbu to the world community of Buddhists as the XIth Panchen Lama at the World Buddhist Forums organized by the Chinese Communist Party (CCP) Central Committee (CC)’s United Front Work Department (UFWD). Beijing has additionally attempted to bring Gyaltsen Norbu to the Buddha’s birthplace at Lumbini in Nepal as part of efforts to “legitimise” him and introduce him to Tibetan Buddhists in the Indo-Himalayan belt. Two determined efforts have thus far failed.
But of late there are signs that Gyaltsen Norbu is possibly not measuring up to the Chinese leadership’s requirements. When Politburo Standing Committee member and Chairman of the Chinese People’s Political Consultative Conference (CPPCC) Wang Huning stayed behind after Xi Jinping’s visit to Tibet and visited Tashilhunpo Monastery in Shigatse on August 23, 2025, the official media did not mention the Panchen Lama as among those who received him. Tashilhunpo is the traditional “seat” and monastery of the Panchen Lama. The Party Secretaries of Shanghai and Sichuan have also separately advised Gyaltsen Norbu to study harder, work diligently to adapt Tibetan Buddhism to socialism with Chinese characteristics, and promote ethnic unity among Tibetans and Han Chinese.
Intervention by China’s leadership escalated on June 6, 2025, when Chinese President Xi Jinping received Gyaltsen Norbu in Beijing in the presence of Politburo Standing Committee members Wang Huning and Cai Qi and Politburo member and Head of the UFWD Li Ganjie. Xinhua’s report indicated that the Chinese leadership was unhappy with the progress made by him in his religious studies.
According to Xinhua, Xi Jinping urged Gyaltsen Norbu to take the 10th Panchen Lama as a role model and become a highly accomplished Tibetan Buddhist reincarnated lama who is deeply respected by both monastic and lay communities. He urged him to contribute more significantly to promoting ethnic unity, religious harmony, and the stable development and progress of Tibet. He urged Gyaltsen Norbu to deepen his religious studies, improve his overall knowledge, and take an active role in fostering a strong sense of Chinese national identity, promoting the Sinicization of religion, and contributing to Tibet’s modernization.
Xi Jinping meeting the China-appointed Panchen Lama is rather unusual. The presence at the meeting of the senior most CCP cadres dealing with Tibet and Tibetan Affairs suggests that some major issues have probably been discussed and, from Xi Jinping’s publicised comments, that the CCP leadership is unhappy with Gyaltsen Norbu’s efforts thus far to establish himself.
More recently, during his visit to Tibet, Gyaltsen Norbu met the then Party Secretary of the Tibet Autonomous Region (TAR), Wang Junzheng on August 3 and was advised to work hard in accordance with Chinese President Xi Jinping’s instructions. He was asked to guide monks, nuns and believers to understand the significance of the CCP’s “Two Establishments”, study the Party’s theories and maintain a high degree of consistency with the CCP Central Committee under Xi Jinping in ideology, politics and action. He emphasised the importance of national unity and territorial integrity and called on Gyaltsen Norbu to “cultivate support” for the CCP, the state and socialism among monks, nuns and believers; publicise laws concerning ethnic unity and progress; strengthen what the authorities called the “sense of community for the Chinese nation”; and continuously enhance the “Five Identifications”. He asked Gyaltsen Norbu to guide religion towards integration with the “fine traditional Chinese culture” and adapt to socialist society.
Despite these efforts though, the Chinese leadership seems to harbour doubts about Gyaltsen Norbu’s reliability and religious capabilities. His visibility in the official Chinese media has dropped appreciably. There was virtually no mention in China’s official media of religious teachings imparted by him in the six months till June 2026, though he is known to have attended a religious symposium in Jiangsu Province and given teachings. The reason for the reduced coverage of Gyaltsen Norbu’s activities at a time when the CCP is trying to promote him is unclear.
Odd too is the visit by Tai Situ Rimpoche of the Karma Kagyu Sect of Tibetan Buddhism to Tibet from early August to mid-September. It comes when the issue of the XIVth Dalai Lama’s reincarnation is gaining increased attention. The visit could not have materialised without permission from Beijing. Tai Situ Rimpoche, who has extensive contacts with Chinese officials in Beijing and Tibet, has been the mentor and spiritual guide of Uyghen Thinley Dorje, who was enthroned by the Chinese as the Gyalwa Karmapa of the Karma Kargyu School of Tibetan Buddhism. Tai Situ Rimpoche met the XIVth Dalai Lama soon after his return, prompting speculation whether he was a messenger to the Chinese.
Intriguing too is that Uyghen Thinley Dorje, the XVIIth Gyalwa Karmapa, Sakya Gongma Trichen Rimpoche (Head of the Sakya School), the Ganden Tripa (Head of the Gelug School) and Ling Rimpoche will all be visiting Bhutan for a week from October 29 to November 7 for a religious ceremony. This will be Uyghen Thinley’s first ever trip to the Drukpa Kagyu kingdom of Bhutan. He has been staying abroad for many years and acquired Dominican nationality.
Whether these visits by Tibetan Buddhism’s high religious personages suggest communications between the XIVth Dalai Lama, Tibetan Buddhists and the Chinese authorities, or is mere coincidence, is presently unclear.
Jayadeva Ranade is a former Member of the National Security Advisory Board and is President of the Centre for China Analysis and Strategy